I'm an adult skater and I've had a single pair of boots during my whole 10 years of skating... Riedell, intermediate level (model 220), that I loved.
Now, looking to buy new boots I thought Riedell was the obvious choice. My bad luck of finding that the not one, but two pairs of Riedel boots were defective, and having to return them, may have been a blessing in disguise because I don't think they fit me well.
I always thought I had narrow foot. When I bought ski boots, my foot was called low volume... whatever that means. I'm finding now that I have medium forefoot, medium heel, medium arch... but low instep, and toes slim in height, hence the low volume, AND I have compressible forefoot. My toes squeeze in narrow boots by compressing. While I don't hurt, that is not good from a medical point of view, but also, because my forefoot doesn't lay flat in boots I cannot control the edges very efficiently.
Now, for the new boots. Riedell has recently redesigned the toe box by to make it more comfortable. All Riedell boots have now a high toe box. Well... it is too high for my slim, or thin toes. I had two insoles in the new Riedell boots I've bought and returned, and I still felt that my toes lifted and I wasn't in control, for example when turning from backward to forward, so when I needed to rock from the front of the blade to the back of the blade.
My bootfitter said, I'm quoting "You may just have to resign yourself to the fact that there is nothing out there that is going to be exactly what you are looking for, and internally modify some stock boot in the best possible way. "But he does not have a clear suggestion on what boot, or boot brand to go to to modify. Riedell doesn't work because of the high toe box. Jackson supposedly also has high toe box and it's wider. I tried Edea and I wasn't crazy about the concept of not feeling the boot snug at the ankle, plus the only model that felt comfortable was the ice fly, that may be too stiff for me. Risport I never tried but it's said to be similar with Edea. Harlick and SP Teri are traditional boot manufacturer that mostly make custom boots. They do have some stock boots. They both are said to have lower toe box but the fit it's different. Different how? How can I try these stock bots? Harlick stock boot is build to order, so I cannot try it, and... it if it doesn't fit, it cannot be returned even if not modified. SP Teri recently changed ownership and supposedly have quality problems so my bootfitter doesn't work with them anymore. These are all the stock boots options...
The next option is semi custom. A stock boot is modified in the factory like in width or stiffness. I called Riedell and they said they cannot modify the toe box as a semi custom option...
The next option is full custom. I'm unclear about this option, can it be ordered by the local bootfitter or will I have to go to the factory? Anyway the custom option is pricey, over $1,000... It will also take few months to get boots. My biggest problem is that is seems it is not certain that custom boots are always a good fit, as per two of my friends that ordered custom boots in the past.
I've decided to do what I did when I was looking for skiing boots, to ask around and to ask in forums. I'm describing my foot shape and hopefully somebody that has a similar foot will have some suggestions.